After trying Caudalie's Beauty Elixir, I felt like I completely gave up on any type of toners. Aggressive, alcohol-packed and overpriced, it was a slap on my wrist as I felt foolish for falling for the hype. Eventually, I came back to my trusty rosewater, it never fails me and I alternate between alverde organic Wild-Rose toner and the Thayers rose petal witch hazel toner.